High Profile cases nothing new to Edward Fleury's lawyer
SPRINGFIELD – High profile cases are nothing new to Rosemary Curran Scapicchio, the Boston lawyer defending former Pelham Police Chief Edward B. Fleury in the involuntary manslaughter case being heard in Hampden Superior Court.
Snow canceled proceedings Wednesday in the Fleury trial, but it is scheduled to continue Thursday in front of Hampden Superior Court Judge Peter A. Velis. William M. Bennett, who is prosecuting the Fleury case, is a known quantity here. Bennett did not run for reelection as Hampden district attorney and ended his 20 years in that post Jan. 5, 2011. Mark G. Mastroianni, the new district attorney, that day swore in Bennett to prosecute the Fleury case, a case Bennett has handled himself since Fleury was indicted. Scapicchio, unlike Bennett, has never been seen before in Hampden Superior Court.
Fleury faces one count of involuntary manslaughter in the death of 8-year-old Christopher Bizilj of Ashford, Conn.
“My first inclination was, ‘There are plenty of good lawyers right there in Springfield,'” she said. Fleury, a man who had “everything on the line,” was insistent she represent him, she said. “It's a very unique case,” Scapicchio said. “It's such a tragedy, but once he brought me the file I really couldn't wrap my head around how it was the commonwealth was going to proceed against him.” She said she sat down with other lawyers with whom she works and “we thought we could do a good job.”
In the Fleury trial, Scapicchio fought vehemently against letting the jury see a videotape of the accidental shooting of Christopher Bizilj. The boy's father, Dr. Charles Bizilj, had been videotaping his son, and Bennett wanted to have the jury see what happened to Christopher. Velis ruled that the jury could see the video with sound included until right after the fatal shot. Then Bennett and Scapicchio argued unsuccessfully that the media should not have access to the video that they jury would see. Scapicchio argued that it would appear on the Internet once it was broadcast by media outlets. Once that happens, she said, the jury will not be able to escape being tainted.
“Once it goes viral no one has control over it anymore,” Scapicchio said. She said the video will likely be shown all over the world and will become the subject of numerous national talk shows from all political persuasions. Editors at MassLive.com and The Republican decided to include part of the video on MassLive.com, but to stop the video before the fatal shot is fired. Other media outlets that showed the video did the same.
Scapicchio said Wednesday the media covering the trial the day the video was shown “was so kind to the family and certainly to Mr. Fleury,” although she would have preferred none of the video be shown by the media. Scapicchio said she was afraid a member of the public might try to use a small video camera in the courtroom as the video was shown and then post it on the Internet. That did not happen.
Fleury is paying Scapicchio for her defense, the lawyer said. Asked if any entity has raised or contributed money for his defense, Scapicchio said she does not know the answer to that because she would get paid by Fleury directly. “I've always been an aggressive attorney,” she said. “In Boston,” she said, “most of the detectives on the homicide unit know who I am and cringe” when they see she is going to cross-examine them. Typically, she said, she is “much more aggressive” cross-examining police detectives than in any cross-examination.
Bennett is scheduled to wrap up the prosecutions case Thursday, and Scapicchio said she will argue to Velis the state did not present enough evidence to send the case to the jury at all and he should dismiss it.