Public feedback from TV coverage of Edward Fluery Trial
Actual TV viewer feedback sent to attorney Rosemay Curran Scapicchio about her trial performance during the week long national television coverage of the Edward Fluery trial
Edward Fleury was charged with one count of involuntary manslaughter and three counts of furnishing a machine gun to a minor for his role in organizing a machine gun shoot at which eight-year-old Christopher Bizilj accidentally shot himself. Fleury organized the gun shoot through his company, C.O.P. Firearms, in conjunction with the Westfield Sportsman's club, as he had done for seven years prior. He hired licensed machine gun manufacturers to bring the weapons to the shoot; the machine gun manufacturers were also in charge of safety of the weapons and the firing line.
Fleury's defense at trial was that the death of Christopher Bizilj was a tragic accident, and that Fleury's actions in organizing the shoot did not cause Christopher Bizilj's death. The evidence presented at trial showed that Christopher Bizilj's father had signed a waiver and affirmed that he understood the dangers accompanying the firing of the weapons at the event, which included serious injury and death, and certified that his sons had adequate training to use those firearms. The evidence further showed that while Christopher Bizilj was shooting, Mr. Fleury was at the gate collecting the five dollar entrance fee. Christopher Bizilj's father selected the weapons for his sons to shoot, including a micro uzi. When the line officer informed Christopher Bizilj's father that he did not think Christopher Bizilj should use the micro uzi because that the weapon shot quickly and kicked back hard, Mr. Bizilj insisted that his son use that weapon. Christopher Bizilj died after he lost control of the micro uzi that he was shooting with the assistance of an instructor.
Moreover, attorney Scapicchio demonstrated to the jury the confusion of the law regarding "furnishing machine guns to minors" which had occurred throughout the state for years, and at this particular machine gun shoot for seven years with the knowledge of the local police department, and without incident or injury. The jury was also presented evidence that demonstrated that Fleury did not own any of the guns, nor did he hand or provide any of those guns to the event's attendees.
The jury found Mr. Fleury not guilty of involuntary manslaughter, and not guilty of three counts of furnishing a machine gun to a minor. Following the not guilty verdicts in Mr. Fleury's case, all charges were dropped against the co-defendants charged in Christopher Bizilj's death.
Actual viewer comments from TV viewer about Rosemary Curran Scapicchio's trial performance:
Oh my goodness you are awesome !!! My grandson and I have been watching you on In Sessions defendant Edward Fleury. We are so into listening to you ,cheering you on. Listening to the staff at In Sessions brag on you Casey Jordan Mike ,Vinny it is sooooo cool!!!! They are saying what we are saying. I said whew she's got a TIGER in her tank and one said you were a Pit Bull ( in a good way)
Anyway I'm just really into court tv and I think this is my first seeing someone as good as you. We certainly are enjoying your professionalism . We will probably be bored after your case is over. Don't know if you care for Nancy Grace but it would be interesting to see you both team up together on a case ! I've been watching In Session for about a year most everyday and you are by far the best Attorney I've seen yet! I'm glad I found a way to let you know what a powerful influence just listening and watching you has been. A pleasure to get to let you know how we feel and to hear the spokes people on In Sessions bragging you up big time!!!!
P.S. Hope to be able to watch more of your cases.
I am a retired police officer living in the Kansas City area. As such, I
have the time to watch court tv (or whatever they call it these days). Over
the years I have watched a number of attorney's both in court locally or on
tv, BUT have never seen any attorney of your caliber. All I can say is you
are the best I have ever seen.
Dear Ms. Scapicchio:
I've watched you during the Fleury trial on TruTV's "In Session." I just felt I must tell you how marvelous and skilled you are in the courtroom. I haven't heard the verdict yet in this particular case, but I have great admiration for your skills, your amazingly sharp mind, and your aggressive style in defending your client.
If I should ever need a defense attorney, I would want nobody else to defend me! I just had to tell you this.
I just wanted to say that i thought you did an outstanding job in the Fleury case that i am watching on "In Session". Great work. I like your style as well.
Dear Ms. Scapicchio,
I've been watching you on truTV and I am an admirer of your style and abilities. Just wanted to say that. I don't need your legal skills, but I am an avid watcher of reality TV and a show about you would be watched by me. Thank you for being such a competent lawyer, and a woman to be proud of.
Wedding minister/Tax Preparer
Dear Ms. Rosemary Scapicchio,
I have been watching the Fleury trial and I want to commend you on your abilities as an attorney. Too bad if witnesses can't keep up. The witness either knows the answer or they don't. If they have to think too long they are probably lying. Forgive me, but I hope you agree that the Prosecutor is a fool. I believe he is prejudice in favor of those in the medical profession. Also, he apparently does not know the rules of law concerning what questions he can ask. He looks like he has been practicing 5 minutes! Either this or he is playing games. This father, if he had been Casey Anthony, he would have been charged with child endangerment. What idiot puts an Uzi in the hands of an 8 year old? I understand he has suffered, however, by law he is not being punished. This is not fair as I am sure you will agree. He signed a waiver and knew the potential consequences and that should be that. This is a terrible accident and the father wants to blame any and everyone else because he can't accept responsibility for putting his son in harms way. Once again, I commend your style in the court room I just hope the jurors are intelligent enough to discern the truth and what is just and fair. My best to you and Chief Fleury.
Dear Ms. Scapicchio,
I am watching you on tv, and just wanted to tell you what an outstanding lawyer you are! I always wanted to be a lawyer and you are very impressive, you really make me regret not pursuing that dream, you are the lawyer I always wanted to be.
I have been watching you on "In Session". You are awesome!! You are a BAAAD mamma jamma! You Go Girl!! Keep up the good work!!
Dayle Childs, TX
Wow...what an attorney. If I never need a lawyer I want you Rosemary. I love your style. Keep up the good work.
Message: I just want to send a quick note to Rosemary to say how much I have respected her in the Fleury trial. Consensus is pretty much in her favor.... we think the father is responsible. Rosemary, thanks for reminding us that there are great defense attorney's still out there!
Just wanted to say wow your the best I ever seen On TV wish you had you own court TV show! I would be watching it all the time haha Keep of the Great work ,,,,,,
Joseph, New Jersey U.S.A.
Message: I have been watching Rosemary Curran Scapicchio on TruTv and I think she is great! I love her style and passion. I hope they show more cases that she has defended.
Message: Just wanted to say Kudo's to you---you have a great style and presentation in court.
Juliet Samba, CT
Message: I just want to say congratulations to you and Mr. Fleury! You presented an OUTSTANDING case. Clearly, Mr. Fleury is innocent and the parent was responsible!!! It was a learning experience for me as a student in paralegal studies. BTW I am 60 years old!
Elliana Agnello, MD
What a brilliant attorney you are. I could only pray to be as quick thinking on my feet as you are. I am a law abiding citizen however, please represent me if I ever get in trouble. OMG Just Awesome. I hope your lawfirm knows how blessed they are to have you.
Donna Weikel, NC
Message: I just wanted to thank Ms. Scapicchio for her amazing service to our judicial system. I have been watching the broadcast of the trial involving the accidental death of Chrispher Bizilj. I cannot tell you how impressed I was with Ms. Scapicchio. As such a horrible accident this was, I was so relieved to know that this innocent man was being represented by such a confident and amazing counselor of the court. She has renewed my faith in the criminal justice system and its ability to provide justice. Thank you and I wish you the best.
Matt Nowak, IL
WOW! It is fair to say you are awesome!!! Watched your trial victory from start to finish and you made it look easy. I have been an expert witness in 61 cases, all wins, and have never seen a quality attorney such as you. Congratulations and can't wait to call you when I am accused of something bad if I can afford you. Congratulations and hope to see you work again.
I just watched you in action on in session with the trial of the 8 year old boy that got killed on the firiring range. what a performance by you and what lawyer skills you have. You are one of the best I have ever seen standing up for what's right. You were absolutely terific what a showman you are.
WOW very impressive!
Message: watched you on in-session..wow I love your work I just wanted to tell you great job for mr flurey, poor guy this was an accident and if the jury would have came back with a guilty verdict that would to me in my own opinion be just as bad as the casy anthoney verdict ..
god bless you.
Message: I watched the entire trial of Mass vs Pelham Police Chief Edward B. Fleury and think you did an awesome job. I dont even know how this case made it to trial, but Fleury was lucky to have you and your staff representing him. I my heart goes out to the family that lost a young boy way to soon, but there is no reason to place blame on anyone. It was an accident. As a LEO, I usually dont like the way defense lawyers manipulate the system, but in this case I felt like you presented the facts and let the jury make their choice. Good Job!
G. Spangler, AZ
Message: I just watched Ms. Scapicchio defend the police chief on Court TV. WOW, she did an amazing job! I would love to base a movie script on her work!!
Nancy Bevins, CA
Dear Ms. Scapicchio:
I am sending this as a viewer of In Session and want to commend you on your verdict today!!! I am a current Criminal Justice student in Richmond, VA and will graduate in March of 2012. I must say you are excellent in what you do and I enjoyed watching you each day "attack" the witnesses. I must say this is the first case I have watched where the Defense attorney didn't call a single witness and didn't need to! I have mentioned to each student in my class as well as friends that if I ever need a criminal attorney, I would certainly want you in my corner. Unfortunately I am in Virginia.
Ms. Scapicchio thank you for who you are and what you stand for. We need more criminal defense lawyers that will stand up for their defendants and not just throw them to the wolves.
Cathy Harris, VA